This document is available in two formats: this web page (for browsing content), and PDF (comparable to original document formatting).

Memorandum U.S. Department of Justice Seal

Subject: Telephone Interview With [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] Date: July 31, 1996

60-2096-0002
To: Files From: William P. Jones   WPJ

Today, Nina Hale and Jill Ptacek spoke with [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)]

distribution:       RWF, DNK, HALE, PTACEK, ALEXANDER - ECON LIT, RUFE, MIKE & HAYES, JOHN - COMP POLICY, SWEENEY, JONES, CASE, CHRON, ARCHIVE


Page(s) 2

Exempt under b4, b7D


[REDACTED TEXT (b7D)]

[REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] snacks strategy (as well as with its other products) is to allocate shelf space to each product category based on accurate sales statistics; [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] allots a normal [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] aisle in its stores to salty snacks and other snack lines based on these modeled electronic demographic data programmed to determine optimal profitability for given stores, given the configurational uniqueness of every store and its demographic considerations. There is no fixed maximum or minimum space restriction on salty snacks placement. [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] relies heavily on the modeling to figure out how everything should unfold. [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] says [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] is known to give a maximum of [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] to salty snacks when justified by demonstrated sales. This does not include separate figures from non-gondola off-shelf displays. [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] offers many satellite displays to snack vendors for product-driving incremental sales. [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] has limited authority to approve such display options throughout the chain.

[REDACTED TEXT (b7D)]

[REDACTED TEXT (b7D)]

Frito-Lay has the majority of snack sales in Southern California [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] And this was always the case, even when Eagle snacks existed and competed head to head with Frito-Lay. When Eagle.exited the market in February of 1996, [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)]

Frito-Lay has different programs for its different products such as potato chips, tortilla chips, etc., on a yearly basis. Its overall program contains allocations of dollars for each segment (potato and tortilla chips, pretzels, cheese items) of its product line. [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)]

Nature of Snack Vendor Negotiations

[REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] and its snack vendors annually negotiate mutual goals in a category management meeting wherefrom a "working game plan" is devised.that is normally not dependent on a written contract. Not only snack vendors but other vendor/manufacturers such as Proctor & Gamble, DelMonte, Kelloggs and Lever Brothers, each national companies, sit down with the grocery chain and negotiate a tentative mutual sales plan for the upcoming year. The basis of the negotiation is normally a measurement of how many "cases of product" the parties expect to be sold during a specified period/year and the vendor will offer a certain dollar amount per case as an allowance; on a one-per-one quid pro quo basis, the vendor pays out an incentive for all sales from Vons. In the snack line [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] expects this customary arrangement of one for one to hold true and finds it has done so reliably and profitably in its recent operation. By terms of the arrangement, each unit sale of product cases brings [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] an award of a future wholesale discount, and this has an rollover effect through the selling year. According to [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] he does not discuss an incremental new year versus old year sales rebate or payment with Frito or anyone. The only allowance ever negotiated between such parties is: "sell one case and you thereby reap a vendor discount." [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] subscribes to no other incentive mechanism in its business. [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] says that [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] receipt of its cash discount prize can either be pocketed for anything the company likes, or it can be applied to advertising promotions for the paying vendor's products if its computer model indicates bottom line major profit enhancement for Vons in doing this. [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] added that to drive sales, [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] modeling structure is conditioned on "delivery of the volume." This is the ultimate goal on its underlying yearly plan. Without a series of incremental year-to-year growth funds to work with and renew, the sole sweetener is structured from direct sales. Usually, [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] is permitted to keep the discount allowances without pressure to divert some of the cash to manufacturer promotions. [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] says there is no "black or white" at [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] executive level in deciding how this bonus money is treated and spent. They decide alone.

[REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] Some products are treated with a slightly different twist. Normally the new item offered to [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] must have an "offset" to protect the retailer; plus, at times, a promotional fee with enough money to "kick off" the new product to the public must also be provided by the manufacturer to aid its chances for successful sales from the outset.

[REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] does not charge for end caps, but its specific Category Manager instead determines (per [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] computer models) whether permitting a vendor certain off-shelf space is in the chain's overall interest. Such a decision is normally reached during yearly negotiations held far in advance of the end cap award. Once again, [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] does not accept additional growth money for end cap and satellite space but relies upon the "one for one, box for box," earned discount sales basis for its end cap income bonus.

[REDACTED TEXT (b7D)]

[REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] shelf space management is based on a simulated computer-generated "space to sales" allocation basis, known technically as "scanned product movement at store level." For this reason, any rash Frito demand, perhaps seen in distant markets, such as "why don't you give 25 extra shelf feet" for maximum sales and incentives for yourself would be met with total denial, based on [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] computer record and [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] policy. In order for F-L to overrule [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] concept, it would have to convince the chain management of a super-profitable interest in promoting the growth of a special sales-leading Frito product and only then might [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] justify a significant (and temporary) space re-allocation. [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] made this prospect sound very unlikely. He said he is not aware of Frito-Lay's present volume and percentage of snack sales at [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] He did not think it was [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] per cent.

Power of the Category Manager

The [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] may discontinue a selected snack manufacturer based on the computer data modeled on a store by store basis. Such a decision is founded on [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] "space to sales" formula and is closely examined. [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] states that his salty snack margins are slightly higher than most products to begin with, but after the frequent and obligatory markdowns to much smaller margins to meet [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] retail competitors, the end salty snack margin is very slim, reflecting a bag price that can drop practically to "cost." Salty snack products often end up being used at strategic times as loss-leaders, such as at Super Bowl week and during the summer when snacks purchases are brisk to lure shoppers into the [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] environment. But [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] noted, it's never necessary for a chain to plummet to the point that it has to sell salty snacks at a loss.

[REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] Policy on Partially Stocked Shelves

At [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] salty snack vendors must keep their product stocked not only at the "space" front facing portion of the gondola, but must fully stock (more or less) all sales racks; any deviation from this rule is unacceptable to [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] Significantly, [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] instituted a new re-set program whereby its stock shelves are stocked by product and not by manufacturer brand, all in one place. All taco chips will be displayed together, as are all brands of pretzels, etc.

Category Captains

[REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] admits that [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] does use "Category Captains" recruited from major vendors in different product categories. He did not know which company was most recently chosen to man the salty snack Category Captain role and now assists [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] He says that the company that is awarded the Category Captain must send an objective person ready to behave [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] not overly partisan for his own company to qualify. The company and its individual must not try to opportunists; if this seems to be the case, that company will be told its person is unacceptable and must leave [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] stated objective is that whoever serves the Category Captain role works strictly in Vons' interest.

SHELF SPACE COMPUTER MODELING

[REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] shelf space management (which is computer based) has a frequency of readjustment that gets triggered by new items coming into the chain and also by a four-week update report created to recap cumulative developments; the Category Manager prepares his own "report card" to the company about the period, providing a new snacks snapshot. His report reviews the chain's category profitability and numerous related factors. [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] says the frequency of computer remodeling is "almost ongoing," akin to a monthly check-up for Vons.

Snack Maker Communication with [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)]

[REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] also stated that there is no salty snack manufacturer minimum space allowance or requirement at [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] but that the "space to sales" formula rules and guides management; it is what [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] cares about on the bottom line. He has not heard of snack vendors complaining or demanding help concerning a desire for minimum linear foot space in order to survive, or a need to show off their great and full product variety. What they do talk about is how to "drive sales" forward and how to initiate sales most effectively at [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] added that [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] calculates into its computer factoring the notion that it really does not need six taco chip competitors on the same shelf, or the like. To help salty snack manufacturers, especially the smaller ones, shelf space boosters such as end caps, towers and islands are offered periodically to enhance their small position and jump sales volume. [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] states that typical [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] store layouts are capacious and generally provide plenty of space for additional satellite displays, should vendors desire to test that area. In addition, there are many [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] stores that provide large standalone space possibilities for niche manufacturers, the little players. [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] states that when negotiations are underway, snack manufacturers are given options that can fold into the deal, such as having 20 end displays and other off-shelf displays during the year. The whole vendor program is more or less agreed upon before the new year starts. Then [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] headquarters tells its stores that there is a certain space available for satellite promotions during a specified time and that, for instance, a beverage like Coke, Gatorade, a named snack food manufacturer, or someone else is supposed to fill this place. This is how Category Managers' yearly programs come together in terms of specific agreement goals between [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] and its vendors.

Shelf Space Advantages and "First Position"

[REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] considers that the only concept of "first position" applicable to [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] is that its own private label products always get first and best location, if at all possible. This is done by human decision, never by remote computer calculation. In this way, [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] Private label products are placed at eye level to the consumer and first position is only sold to a company like Frito on a negotiated, high-cost basis.

PROSPECT OF NEW SNACK MANUFACTURER COMING TO [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)]

Asked whether [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] would permit a new snack manufacturer to come into its chain, [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] stated that it would be possible and that the following procedure would obtain: 1) The snack manufacturer would have to prove that it had a strong marketing program such as a television, radio or other vehicle advertising platform, much like Frito-Lay projects; 2) It would have to have a unique product or products that could ensure good sales; and, 3) its quality would have to be absolutely superb.

All of these factors would have to be demonstrated for a new salty snack manufacturer to enter [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] sales domain. [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] stated that there would be no special fees extracted from such a new snack manufacturer other than the fees previously indicated above [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] closed by telling us [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] would be eager to give space to a new manufacturer if it came as a reliable manufacturer. Asked his response if Frito-Lay tried to throw money at [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] to block entry of a new snack line, he said [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] would reject Frito's bid.

Finally, [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] was not aware of any Frito rebates or end year payments that Frito would have recently started supplying to [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] He restated that snack vendors pay only discounts on pure box for box sales results, and that would continue to be [REDACTED TEXT (b7D)] corporate policy.

So/So # 12099