This document is available in two formats: this web page (for browsing content) and PDF (comparable to original document formatting). To view the PDF you will need Acrobat Reader, which may be downloaded from the Adobe site. For an official signed copy, please contact the Antitrust Documents Group.

Comment No.: REW-0376
Received: 11/21/2005
Organization: J. Roberts and Company
Commenter: Marsh, Robert
State: AZ
Attachments: None


Comments:

From: bmarsh@jrobertsandco.com [mailto:bmarsh@jrobertsandco.com]
Sent: Monday, November 21, 2005 12:16 PM
To: ATR-Real Estate Workshop
Subject:


Robert N. 'Bob' Marsh, CRS, GRI
Designated Broker
J. Roberts and Company
6263 N. Scottsdale #295A
Scottsdale, AZ 85250
480-483-6464,Toll free 1-866-483-6464
Cell: 480-529-2936, Fax: 602-388-8195
bmarsh@jrobertsandco.com


November 21, 2005

Antitrust Division
U.S. Department of Justice
Liberty Place, Suite 300
Attention: Lee Quinn
325 7th Street, NW
Washington, DC 20530

RE: Competition and the Real Estate Workshop - Comment, Project No. V050015

To Whom It May Concern:

I have been active in the real estate industry as a sales professional since 1977. Whew! Is it ever competitive. I would challenge anyone who has thoughts to the contrary to go into any real estate market in the United States and search out the number of transactions each month and divide by the number of real estate practitioners licensed and actively doing business in that locality. The numbers will bear out that there is a definite competition for each and every transaction. Not only do you have small ratio when looking at trades per licensee, you still have to divide the total transactions by two - one side for the sale and one for the listing - in most cases the licensee does not represent both the buyer and the seller.

Another indicator of the competitive nature of the business is evidenced by the number of licensees who enter the business and exit the business in a short time - they cannot make a living on so few transactions.

We compete every day for the opportunity to perform service for the buyer or for the seller. The real estate business is not a retail business, but a service business. We are not unlike attorneys who represent clients. Many attorneys do not advertise for their business, but as a real estate practitioner, if we do not advertise, we do not attract the business needed to continue in this competitive business.

As for competitive "policy" in the real estate industry - there is no policy except for survival of the fittest. There is no collusion determining how we compete. Granted, there may be some rules and ethics to follow, but our spirit of competition with cooperation does not constitute a "policy". Whatever we do in cooperation is not unlike the information system doctors use in prescribing the right cure for their patient's ills - if doctor's did not work together, illness could perpetuate - if real estate practitioners did not work together, clients needs would not be met.

Our competition is healthy, alive and for the good of mankind, how is yours?

Respectfully submitted,
Robert N. Marsh
5013 E. Flossmoor Avenue
Mesa, Arizona 85206