| |
|
| |
3-3.1 - INITIAL DEBTOR INTERVIEWS (IDIs)
|
| |
Immediately following the entry
of an order for relief, the United States Trustee should schedule
an initial debtor interview ("IDI") with the principals of the
debtor and debtor's counsel. The purpose of the IDI is two-fold:
(1) to provide the United States Trustee with vital information
so that an early assessment can be made as to the veracity of
the debtor's schedules and statements and the debtor's financial
ability to reorganize; and (2) to ensure the debtor is aware
of its new fiduciary obligations and the United States Trustee's
role in the administration of chapter 11 cases. |
| |
|
|
| |
|
3-3.1.1 - Procedure for Setting Up the
IDI |
| |
|
The United States Trustee
should advise the debtor's principals and debtor's counsel,
in writing, that an IDI has been set at a tentative date and
time. Reasonable effort should be made to accommodate the
various individuals' schedules. While it is preferable to
conduct the meeting in person, factors such as the small size
or lack of complexity of a case, as well as the resources
available in the local office, may warrant alternative arrangements.
For example, a telephone conference with the debtor can be
conducted. Regardless of the method employed, it is vital
that contact with representatives of the debtor be promptly
initiated and that the IDI be held prior to the section 341
meeting.
Prior to the IDI, the United States Trustee should make
a written request for certain financial and other information
pertaining to the debtor's business or affairs. The request
can vary depending on the nature or size of the business.
Typically, financial statements, prepetition bank statements
and checks, federal tax returns, material lawsuits, and executory
contracts should be requested. The debtor should also be asked
to provide documentation such as proof of a debtor in possession
account, evidence of insurance, as well as counsel's employment
order, to ensure the case is in administrative compliance.
Regardless of the debtor's complete compliance, the IDI should
proceed. |
| |
|
|
| |
|
3-3.1.2 - United States Trustee's Initial
Assessment of the Case |
| |
|
The primary focus of the IDI
is to gather key financial and background information on the
debtor's business, focusing on the past, the present, and
the future. The debtor should be encouraged to provide a historical
background of the business, its principals, and its products
or services. Key customers, primary creditors, major contracts,
and significant lawsuits, if any, should be identified and
discussed. The immediate and underlying reason(s) for the
filing of the chapter 11 bankruptcy should be fully addressed.
The debtor and debtor's counsel should be asked to identify
the immediate hurdles which must be overcome to stabilize
the business. Questions about how the debtor plans to proceed
through chapter 11 and, ultimately, resolve the case, including
a tentative timetable, should be raised. The United States
Trustee may also discuss the debtor's accounting controls.
Finally, the debtor's schedules and statements should be reviewed
carefully with the debtor and debtor's counsel in order to
identify any inconsistencies or omissions based upon the information
disclosed during the IDI.
At the conclusion of the IDI, the United States Trustee
should make an initial assessment as to the accuracy of the
debtor's schedules and statements, whether financial reorganization
is a viable option for this debtor, and what case management
tools and alternatives should be considered given the circumstances
of the case. The key information gathered at the IDI and the
initial assessment should be set forth in a written report
so that it can be more readily used by the United States Trustee
case attorney for reference during the section 341 meeting
and for general case management purposes. |
| |
|
|
| |
|
3-3.1.3 - Familiarizing the Debtor with
its New Fiduciary Obligations |
| |
|
At the IDI, the United States
Trustee should set forth the statutory duties and obligations
of a debtor in possession. The debtor's representatives should
be provided with a copy of the Program's chapter 11 operating
guidelines and monthly report forms, which should be explained
and discussed. The procedures for calculating and paying the
quarterly fee assessed pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1930(a)(6)
should be explained. The United States Trustee should ensure
that the debtor has closed its former bank accounts and established
separate debtor in possession bank accounts. The debtor should
be required to provide proof that appropriate insurance coverage
is being maintained. If applicable, the statutory requirements
regarding the use of cash collateral should be explained.
The role of the United States Trustee in the administration
of chapter 11 cases should be explained to the debtor. The
debtor should be advised that the United States Trustee will
take appropriate measures to protect creditors' interests
and the circumstances under which the United States Trustee
will take such action.
Information and commitments regarding either compliance
matters or document requests which are obtained from the debtor's
representatives at the IDI should be documented and retained
in the case file. A specific time frame within which any outstanding
deficiencies or issues will be resolved should be established
prior to the conclusion of the IDI. The debtor's failure to
adhere to any such agreement should result in prompt action
by the United States Trustee. |
| |
|
| |
3-3.2 - OPERATING GUIDELINES |
| |
The operating guidelines for
chapter 11 debtors are an important facet of the United States
Trustee's efforts to monitor the administration of chapter 11
cases. They address the subject areas discussed in the following
subsections. |
| |
|
| |
3-3.2.1 - General Provisions |
| |
The debtor should be advised of its obligation
to comply with the Bankruptcy Code, the Federal Rules of Bankruptcy
Procedure, local rules, and any court order, and that postpetition
debts must remain current and prepetition debts may not be paid.
The debtor should be instructed to close its books and records
as of the date of filing and to open new postpetition books
and records. The debtor should be notified that pleadings and
notices are to be served upon the United States Trustee and
an appropriate mailing address should be given to do so. Finally,
the debtor should be advised of the consequences of failing
to comply with the operating guidelines and reporting requirements.
The United States Trustee should specifically spell out the
method of calculating and paying the United States Trustee's
quarterly fees. |
| |
|
|
| |
|
3-3.2.2 - Bank Accounts |
| |
|
The operating guidelines
contain a requirement that the debtor close its prepetition
bank accounts and open new debtor in possession accounts.
Absent court authorization, the accounts may be maintained
only in depositories that agree to post a bond or pledge securities
for all deposits not insured or guaranteed by the United States
or by a department, agency, or instrumentality of the United
States, or backed by the full faith and credit of the United
States. 11 U.S.C. § 345(b). The debtor should establish
a separate general account for the purpose of paying bills
incurred during the administration of the case. The debtor
should also establish a separate tax trust account so that
it may escrow the necessary funds for the payment of postpetition
taxes (including, for example, payroll and sales or excise
taxes) when such liabilities are incurred.
The debtor may also be required to establish separate accounts
for such items as payroll and payments to secured creditors.
Savings accounts and certificates of deposit may be maintained
as well, pursuant to the statutory obligation to obtain a
safe, yet reasonable, return on estate funds for the benefit
of creditors. See 11 U.S.C. § 345(a). The debtor
in possession's account checks and statements should be imprinted
with the phrase "Debtor in Possession." For example, the checks
could be styled as follows:
Estate of XYZ Corporation
Debtor in Possession
101 Main Street
Anywhere, U.S.A. 11111
This caption on the checks is intended to notify creditors
and third parties that the debtor is operating under the protection
of the bankruptcy court. Notice is thereby given to all persons
who may receive the check that they are doing business with
a debtor and that they may have different rights and responsibilities
than when dealing with a non-debtor individual or entity,
i.e., that they may have an administrative claim if the check
is not honored. Creditors receiving such checks for the improper,
unauthorized payment of prepetition debts may disclose this
information to the court and the United States Trustee, who
may take corrective action. In re Young, 205 B.R. 894
(Bankr. W.D. Tenn. 1997); In re Gold Standard Baking, Inc.,
179 B.R. 98 (Bankr. N.D. Ill. 1995); In re Johnson,
106 B.R. 623 (Bankr. D. Neb. 1989) (debtors not required to
imprint "debtor in possession" on checks). |
| |
|
|
| |
|
3-3.2.3 - Insurance |
| |
|
A debtor must maintain appropriate
insurance coverage, and documentation regarding the existence
of the coverage must be provided to the United States Trustee
as early in the case as possible.
The dollar amount of the insurance coverage must be sufficient
to cover the fair market value of the estate's property. Information
about the fair market value of the property can be derived
from such sources as the testimony of the debtor's principal,
the schedules and statement of financial affairs, and appraisals
prepared in connection with financing or valuation hearings.
The extent of coverage must be adequate, given the circumstances
of the case. Depending on the case, the debtor may be required
to maintain all or a combination of fire and extended liability
insurance, general liability insurance, worker's compensation
and unemployment insurance, employee health insurance (especially
if pursuant to a collective bargaining agreement or retirement
plan; see 11 U.S.C. §§ 1113 and 1114), malpractice
insurance, product liability insurance, and liquor or dramshop
insurance. Insurance companies and agents should be instructed
to provide the United States Trustee with prior notification
regarding any change, cancellation, or expiration of a debtor's
insurance policy. A debtor should also be required to provide
separate notice to the United States Trustee regarding any
change in insurance coverage. |
| |
|
| |
3-3.3 - FINANCIAL REPORTS |
| |
The timely filing of reports
of operations is crucial to the efficient administration of
chapter 11 cases. These reports are designed to provide the
United States Trustee, the court, creditors, and other parties
in interest with reliable information regarding the current
status of a Case. The United States Trustee should use the
information contained in the reports to identify cases lacking
a realistic prospect of reorganization and to evaluate the
feasibility of a proposed plan of reorganization.
The debtor in possession should file operating reports each
month throughout the pendency of the case. A deadline for
the submission of the initial report should be set at the
initial debtor interview. The report should be filed with
both the United States Trustee and the clerk of the court.
The debtor should also provide a copy of the report to the
Chair of any creditors' committee appointed to serve in the
case.
The United States Trustee retains the discretion to waive
or modify the reporting requirements. The rationale underlying
any such decision, however, should be documented in writing
and maintained in the file. Moreover, this discretion should
be exercised sparingly, given both the importance of timely
and accurate financial information in the reorganization process,
as well as the need to avoid the appearance that a debtor
is receiving disparate treatment. The debtor's obligation
to file monthly operating reports ends when a case is converted
or dismissed. Postconfirmation, the United States Trustee
should require submission and filing of reports pursuant to
11 U.S.C. § 1106(a)(7). See USTM
3-10.7.
Different reporting formats may be used for different types
of cases. For example, the operating report form used for
a case involving an ongoing manufacturing concern may be different
from the form more suitable for use in a real estate case.
Generally, the debtor's operating reports should be premised
on the accrual basis of accounting. Under this method, revenue
is considered earned in the period in which sales are made
or services are rendered (regardless of when payment is collected),
and expenses are considered in the period in which they are
incurred regardless of when they are paid.
The operating report form used in a standard business reorganization
under chapter 11 should encompass the elements described in
the following subsections. |
| |
|
|
| |
|
3-3.3.1 - Cash Receipts and Disbursements
Statement |
| |
|
The United States Trustee
should require the submission of cash statements showing the
receipts and disbursements of the debtor, as well as a separate
cash account reconciliation statement for each of its bank
accounts, e.g., general account, tax escrow account, and payroll
account. The information contained in these statements will
reflect whether the debtor's operations are generating a positive
cash flow. The information should be analyzed with appropriate
consideration given to the seasonality of the debtor's business
and any historical information that is relevant.
Aside from the income and other items comprising cash receipts,
the cash statement should contain the debtor's expenditures
for inventory, salaries, taxes, etc. The United States Trustee
can use the information reported in these statements to discover:
- whether the debtor is making unauthorized payments to
professionals;
- whether the debtor is improperly paying prepetition debts;
- whether the debtor has sufficient cash flow to effectively
reorganize;
- whether inordinate payments are being made for travel,
entertainment, or other employee benefits; and,
- whether improper payments are being made by the debtor
that will hamper its ability to reorganize.
|
| |
|
|
| |
|
3-3.3.2 - Statement of Operations |
| |
|
The debtor should provide
a regular monthly statement of operations (income statement)
that indicates whether the debtor is generating sufficient
funds to reorganize. The statement of operations form is a
comparative statement designed to allow the United States
Trustee to review all the information from a particular debtor
on one spreadsheet.
A detailed review and analysis of this statement is important
as it provides a better picture of a debtor's operations than
does the cash statement. Many expenses are paid less frequently
than on a monthly basis. In addition, there are non-cash accounts
(e.g., depreciation and amortization) that do not appear on
a cash statement, yet must be taken into account in analyzing
the ongoing viability of the debtor. For example, although
depreciation is a non-cash item, the debtor will eventually
need to buy new machinery and equipment or pay for other capital
improvements.
The accrual income statement is also important since it
indicates the cost of goods sold. This requires a beginning
inventory figure based upon a physical or perpetual inventory.
The beginning inventory figure is critical since it is only
after purchases have been added and ending inventory deducted
that one arrives at the cost of goods sold. This will determine
the debtor's gross profit margin. At this point, a comparative
financial analysis can be accomplished using statistics from
prior years. |
| |
|
|
| |
|
3-3.3.3 - Balance Sheet |
| |
|
The debtor is required to
provide a balance sheet on a monthly basis to allow the United
States Trustee to review the debtor's changing assets and
debts on a single spreadsheet.
Careful analysis of the balance sheet is required as it
can uncover whether the debtor is making payments on prepetition
debts, whether assets are being dissipated, and whether the
debtor is accumulating unpaid postpetition liabilities and
uncollected postpetition accounts receivable. If any of these
occur, the United States Trustee should take appropriate action.
|
| |
|
|
| |
|
3-3.3.4 - Schedule of Postpetition Liabilities |
| |
|
The debtor should provide an
accounting of the amount of obligations unpaid since the commencement
of the case, as well as an aging schedule for these sums. If
the total amount of unpaid obligations increases and the amounts
owed are becoming further past due, it may indicate a negative
cash flow and/or administrative insolvency. However, there will
almost always be certain postpetition obligations which have
not been paid simply because they have not become due in the
ordinary course of business or because their payment is not
yet authorized (e.g., payment of attorney or accountant fees). |
| |
|
|
| |
|
3-3.3.5 - Postpetition Taxes Payable (Tax
Reconciliation) Statement |
| |
|
The taxes payable or tax
reconciliation statement provides a means for monitoring and
verifying that a debtor is current with its postpetition tax
obligations. Aging information about these obligations should
be provided. Close scrutiny of this form is critical and prompt
remedial action should be undertaken by the United States
Trustee if unpaid postpetition obligations accumulate.
The United States Trustee should maintain an information
exchange program with the Special Procedures Staff of the
Internal Revenue Service. This exchange will provide an independent
means of checking and verifying the debtor's information regarding
federal tax obligations. The Internal Revenue Service, in
turn, is authorized to notify the United States Trustee when
its records indicate that a debtor has failed to satisfy a
postpetition tax obligation. |
| |
|
|
| |
|
3-3.3.6 - Additional Reporting Requirements |
| |
|
In addition to the five standard
forms previously discussed, the United States Trustee retains
the discretion to require any additional reports necessary
to ensure that a case is properly monitored and administered.
Examples would include:
- A requirement that copies of previous years' tax returns
and financial statements be filed with the United States
Trustee.
- A requirement that a debtor file a list of inventory.
- A requirement that a debtor file a list of its employees
and their current salaries.
- A requirement that a debtor provide an aging statement
regarding its accounts receivable.
- In a real estate case, a requirement that a debtor submit
a rent roll.
- A requirement that a debtor submit a check register.
- A requirement that a debtor submit a statement of sources
and uses of cash (Cash Flow Statement).
|
|