U.S. Department of Justice
Washington, D.C. 20530
Evaluation of the Handling of
the Branch Davidian Stand-off
in Waco, Texas
February 28 to April 19, 1993
Edward S.G. Dennis, Jr.
October 8, 1993
TABLE OF CONTENTS
- COULD THE FBI HAVE PREVENTED THE DEATHS OF THE
- WAS THE FBI'S NEGOTIATION STRATEGY AND ITS
IMPLEMENTATION ADEQUATE TO RESOLVE THE
CONFRONTATION WITH THE BRANCH DAVIDIANS?
- WAS THE DECISION MAKING PROCESS FOR FORMULATION,
APPROVAL, AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE PLAN FOR THE TEAR
GAS INSERTION ADEQUATE?
This is a critical retrospective evaluation of the activities of the United States
Department of Justice ("Department") and the Federal Bureau of Investigation ("FBI")
during the fifty-one day stand-off at the Branch Davidians' Mt. Carmel compound near
Waco, Texas which ended on April 19, 1993 when fire consumed the compound, killing
David Koresh and most of his followers. To make this evaluation, I have reviewed the
procedures followed by the Department and the FBI, giving particular attention to the
means employed, the alternatives considered and the decisions made in attempting to
resolve the stand-off.
I have not been called upon to conduct a de novo factual inquiry. A comprehensive
factual report is being prepared by the Department and the FBI. I have primarily relied
upon the record gathered by the Department as the basis for the conclusions in this
Report, supplemented by a number of follow-up interviews. However, I am satisfied that
the factual inquiry by the Department was conducted in a thorough and objective manner.
Prior to my appointment, the Department had completed over 800 field interviews
and gathered pertinent documentation. They continued to gather documents and conduct
interviews thereafter. I have been afforded access to documents gathered in that effort and
to the reports of interviews conducted for the factual investigation. In addition, since my
appointment I participated in a number of Department interviews. I have also conducted
independent interviews of some witnesses.
The scope of this Report is confined to the activities of the Department and the FBI.
I have not been asked to evaluate and I make no judgments about the activities of the
Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms ("ATF") leading up to the February 28, 1993
gun battle at Mount Carmel. I have been assisted in my investigation and writing of this
Report by Ms. Suzan E. DeBusk, Esq. whose invaluable contribution, I gratefully
After reviewing the stand-off at Waco, including the progress of the negotiations and
the conception, approval and implementation of the tear gas plan on April 19, 1993, this
Report concludes as follows.
The fire on April 19, 1993 was deliberately set by persons inside the compound and was
not started by the FBI's tear gas insertion operations. It is not certain, however, whether a
substantial number of the persons who died in the compound on April 19 remained inside
voluntarily, were being held in the compound against their will or were shot in order to prevent
their escape from the fire. Preliminary medical reports are that a substantial number of
individuals had died of gunshot wounds. Among those shot were young children. Koresh's body
was found with a gunshot wound to the forehead. The FBI did not fire on the compound during
the tear gas operation, although shots were fired at the FBI from the compound. The FBI did not
fire on the compound at any time during the fifty-one day stand-off.
The evidence forecasting David Koresh's intention to orchestrate a mass suicide was
contradictory. Koresh and his followers repeatedly assured the negotiators that they did
not intend to commit suicide. On several occasions agents were told that suicide was
against the Davidians' religious beliefs. However, one released member said there was a
suicide plan. Other released members denied there was a suicide plan. In any event, the
risk of suicide was taken into account during the negotiations and in the development of
the gas plan.
The FBI developed a coherent negotiating strategy to talk the Davidians out. However,
the negotiators had strong objections to pressure tactics they felt were counterproductive.
The use of pressure tactics immediately after Koresh sent out Davidians from the compound
may have undermined the negotiators' credibility and blunted their efforts to gain the
Davidians' trust and to discredit Koresh in the eyes of his followers. Nevertheless, tactical
actions designed to increase the safety margin for agents were appropriately given priority
over negotiating considerations. I conclude that the events of April 19 were the result of
David Koresh's determined efforts to choreograph his own death and the deaths of his
followers in a confrontation with federal authorities to fulfill Koresh's apocalyptic prophesy.
The deaths of Koresh, his followers and their children on April 19th were not the result of
a flaw in the gas plan or the negotiation strategy.
The FBI used many qualified experts, including its own FBI behavioral experts to
evaluate Koresh. Their assessments were thorough and many proved quite accurate.
REDACTED FROM PUBLIC REPORT PENDING RELEASE OF
The Attorney General was adequately briefed on the tear gassing plan, was fully
informed of the options, and was given a realistic appraisal of the risks. All reasonable
alternatives were considered and the decision to insert CS gas was a reasonable one. I
conclude that an indefinite siege was not a realistic option. According to the plan, gas
would be inserted in stages and the FBI would wait 48 hours for it to have an effect. As
the plan was being implemented, the tanks were ordered to enlarge openings in the
compound to provide escape routes for the Davidians.
The FBI did anticipate that a fire might occur at the compound. Fire fighting equipment
was not kept close to the scene because the heavy weaponry used by Koresh and his followers
presented unacceptable risks to fire fighters. In any event, the independent arson experts
concluded that the fire spread so quickly in the poorly constructed compound that even prompt
fire fighting efforts would have been ineffective.
The FBI exhibited extraordinary restraint and handled the crisis with great professionalism.
ATF requested assistance from the FBI on February 28, 1993 after ATF agents had attempted
to serve an arrest and search warrant on the Branch Davidian Compound. Four ATF agents were
killed, 20 agents wounded and an unknown number of Davidians were killed and wounded in the
ensuing gun battle.
The FBI assembled a group of its best and most experienced negotiators from its Critical
Incident Negotiations Team ("CINT"). The FBI's behavioral experts from its National Center
for the Analysis of Violent Crime ("NCAVC") were assigned to assess the behavior of Koresh
and his followers. ATF specifically requested the assistance of the FBI's Hostage Rescue Team
("HRT"), a highly trained and rigorously selected counter terrorist unit designed for high threat
tactical assignments. FBI SWAT teams were deployed along with a full crisis management
team consisting of three SACs and four ASACs supervising two command posts with full
technical support. The FBI arrived at Mt. Carmel on February 28, set up its command posts and
began telephone negotiations with the people inside the compound. It was estimated that over 100
men, women and children with nearly 250 weapons were inside the compound. The compound
was stocked with a year's supply of food rations and was otherwise prepared to withstand an
extended siege. David Koresh, the group's charismatic leader, had been wounded in the gun
battle with ATF.
Early negotiations were successful, and twenty-one children and two elderly adults exited
the compound during the first six days of the stand-off. On the evening of February 28, 1993
Koresh promised that if a recorded message from him were played on a certain radio station,
children would be released from the compound two-by-two. The message was played for the
first time at approximately 7:30 that evening. About an hour later two children, Angelica and
Crystal Sonobe, were escorted out of the compound by their mother, who went back in. The
message was rebroadcast and two more children, Rene Fagan and Nehara Fagan, were released.
The next morning at 6:30 two more children were released; at 10:30 two more were released;
at 4:00 two more were released; at 8:30 two more were released and at 11:00 two more were
The next day, on March 1, 1993 the negotiator asked Koresh if he was going to commit
suicide and he replied "I'm not going to commit suicide." He also stated "if I wanted to commit
suicide, I would have done it already." The negotiator asked Koresh, "Are you going to let any
of your other people kill themselves or die in there?" Koresh replied "I'm not going to do that."
The night of March 1 Koresh advised that everyone would come out if a tape he recorded
were played on the radio. On the morning of March 2, 1993 detailed arrangements were made
for the surrender of Koresh and the other Davidians upon the playing of the tape. Koresh agreed
he would be carried out on a stretcher and would go to a Bradley ambulance with three of the
children, while everyone else would go to a waiting bus. Koresh was to exit first while Steve
Schneider1 was to remain in the compound to coordinate the release of the remaining members at
one minute intervals. Emergency and transport vehicles were positioned.
Koresh recorded his tape and at the negotiators' request recorded a preamble affirming his
promise to surrender. During the day of March 2, two elderly women, Katherine Matteson and
Margaret Lawson, and four children exited the compound. Koresh was questioned about suicide
and stated, "I dont think anyone's going to commit suicide."
The tape was broadcast as agreed between 1:30 and 2:30 p.m. an March 2. The Davidians
then advised that they were moving Koresh down the stairs on the stretcher, but that he was in
pain from his gunshot wounds suffered in the February 28 shoot-out. Progress was delayed when
Koresh began a prayer session. Then Schneider began to preach to the negotiators. Finally,
Schneider informed the negotiators that "God had told Koresh to wait". By the evening of March 2,
other Davidians had come to the phone and advised the negotiators that "God had told Koresh to
wait." Koresh would not come to the phone.2
Meanwhile the United States Attorney's office had arrested and charged the two elderly
women who had exited the compound with conspiracy to commit murder. On March 3, 1993
the Davidians heard a broadcast on CNN reporting the arrests. The FBI consolidated log
reflects concern by the negotiators that if the Davidians heard of the arrest it would have a
"devastating effect" on the negotiations. The FBI immediately persuaded the United States
Attorney's office to drop the charges and hold the women as material witnesses instead. The
compound was immediately notified of that fact.
At this time military style vehicles were visible from the compound. This was contrary to
the advice of some of the negotiators and behavioral scientists, who advised that threatening
activities would not be effective against Koresh and his followers and would likely draw them
closer together. Steve Schneider complained that the tanks were running over the guard shacks
and stated that it is "part of a program of intimidation."
Later on March 3 the negotiators were told that if Koresh were allowed to give a "bible study"
then the child Mark Jones would be released. The study was given and Jones was promptly
released. His brother Kevin was also released the next day and his sister Heather was released on
March 5. Heather Jones would be the last child released.
Contact with Koresh over the next month and a half met with limited success. Koresh
continued to use the children as a shield against FBI efforts to resolve the stand-off. Koresh
threatened to fire on FBI positions and to blow up government vehicles. The bulk of Koresh's
contact with FBI consisted of proselytizing the negotiators in marathon sermons of rambling
exhortations. Koresh claimed to be Christ and to have knowledge of the seven seals of the
apocalypse. Twelve more adults would exit the compound over the next eighteen days, but
Koresh would refuse to leave claiming that his followers were free to make their own decisions
whether to, remain in the compound with him. More than seventy would perish with Koresh on
On March 5 Koresh requested a suture kit for his hand, a videotape of the released children
and six gallons of milk for the children within the compound. All of these requests were granted.
The Davidians began requesting that Peter Gent's body be removed. Gent had been killed in the
February 28 shoot-out with the ATF and his body remained outside the compound. They also
demanded a line to the media and asked that the Bradley military vehicles be removed from the
These requests were denied.
On March 6, 1993 Koresh told the negotiators that if he were allowed to speak with
an ATF undercover agent, then he would send Melissa Morrison, a six year old girl, out of the
compound. Melissa came to the phone and said she would like to leave. Her mother gave
instructions for family members to care for her. The negotiators told Koresh that the agent
was not in Waco. Melissa Morrison was not released and presumably died in the April 19,
On March 7 Koresh stated that if the negotiators' could "show him" the third seal of the
apocalypse, then he would release some children. The negotiator attempted to discuss the
seal, but Koresh stated that the negotiator had "failed" and refused to release anyone. Davidian
member Wayne Martin 3 then came to the phone and demanded a line to the media so that they
could find a lawyer to file a lawsuit against the government. Juliette Martinez over the telephone
told the negotiators that if she came out they would separate her from her children and put her
in jail. This day there were 42 separate conversations lasting eleven and a half hours.
The morning of March 8 three Davidians buried the body of Peter Gent. Later that day
Waco Sheriff Jack Harwell was allowed to speak with Koresh as a negotiator. Koresh told the
sheriff not to worry because they were not going to commit suicide. He asked for milk and told
the sheriff that he had sent out money to pay for those necessities. Shortly after that conversation
6 gallons of milk were sent in. That night the Davidians sent out a videotape of the children in the
compound. The negotiators' log shows that when the tape was reviewed there was concern that
if the tape were released to the media Koresh would gain much sympathy.
On March 9 at about 2:15 a.m. power to the compound was cut off. Later that morning
two public address speakers with 100 watt amplifiers were set up. Koresh stated that if the
FBI did not turn the power back on, he would not communicate. Power was restored about
10:30 that morning, so that the Davidians could listen to the daily press conference. Later
that afternoon the Davidians displayed a banner from the compound reading "God help us,
we want the press."
The evening of March 9 the negotiators had a conversation with Judy Schneider and
Rachel Koresh,4 both of whom wanted a doctor to be sent in to treat Judy's finger, which had
been wounded in the shoot-out. The negotiator refused and told Judy to come out to be treated.
The negotiator then had a conversation with Steve Schneider and told him to turn off the
halogen lights pointing out to the perimeter or power would again be cut off. There was concern
about the Davidians using the lights to monitor FBI movements around the perimeter. The
Davidians delivered another videotape out of the compound that night.
About 2:30 in the morning on March 10 power to the compound was cut off again. It appears
to have been turned back on later in the day. Some clearing of the grounds must have occurred
that day as well, because that evening Schneider complained about the destruction of a Harley
Around 1:00 in the morning of March 11 Schneider told the negotiators that three people
might be coming out the next day. There was conversation throughout the day about who would
be coming out and what would happen to them if they came out. Also that day Schneider told the
negotiators that they had heard a radio broadcast about a shooting star called the "guitar nebula,"
and that Koresh had taken it as a sign. The negotiators felt encouraged that this "sign" could be a
face saving action allowing Koresh to surrender peacefully. At Schneider's request, the negotiators
read Koresh a newspaper article about the nebula. However, Koresh said it was not the sign he
was waiting for.
On the morning of March 12 Kathy Schroeder 5 left the compound, expressing a desire to
be reunited with her four children who had already been released. Her reunion with her youngest
child was filmed and sent back into the compound. She asked to be allowed to call back into
the compound in order to give the other members some confidence in the system because they
were afraid, not knowing what to expect, and she was allowed to do so. In her interview
immediately after her exit Schroeder stated that God had told Koresh not to commit suicide.
She also said that there were people inside who wanted to come out, but that Koresh had a
"total hold" on them. She said many would come out if Koresh told them to, but he would not.
After Schroeder's exit, Steve Schneider began making many demands, including a copy
of the transcript of Kiri Jewell's 6 television appearance, contact with the media, contact with
attorneys and a radio personality to serve as the Davidians' press representative. After these
demands the negotiators were unable to get through to the compound for five hours. During
this time 6 gallons of milk were delivered into the compound. Schneider finally answered the
phone, claimed that there had been mechanical difficulties, and reported that Koresh was
very upset about a radio broadcast that his mother had received $75,000 for the movie rights
to her story. That evening Oliver Gyarfas exited the compound. Judy Schneider was allowed
to speak to a physician on the phone about her injured hand. After Schroeder and Gyarfas
left the compound, the on scene commander decided that power to the compound would be
turned off that night. The negotiators advised against cutting off the power that night after two
people had come out and more were anticipated to come out. They argued that, it would
hurt the negotiations effort and would cause them a set back at a crucial time in the negotiations.
The justification for cutting the power was that it was going to be a very cold night and
maximum effect would be gained in making the Davidians uncomfortable inside the compound.
Also, cutting the power was designed to challenge Koresh's control of the situation and to
raise the level of stress within the compound to force more departures.
Power to the compound was cut off at 11:00 the night of March 12. Koresh then told
the negotiators that people had changed their minds about coming out because of the power
shut off. Schneider stated that the power shut off was a "huge, huge set-back," and that
he had been considering coming out himself, but had changed his mind because of it. The
power remained out that night and the FBI began using the loudspeakers and shining the
lights on the compound. It was determined that the negotiators would not call into the
compound, but would only answer when they were called. The negotiators were not able
to get through to the compound most of the time on March 13.
On March 14 Oliver Gyarfas was allowed to call into the compound. He stated that
the authorities were treating him well and that he had access to the press. Kathy Schroeder
also spoke to them and said she was treated well and had access to a phone, but she would
not speak to the press until they all came out to tell their story. She urged Schneider to
come out peacefully and told him that time was not on his side. During the night of March
14 and early morning hours of March 15 additional lights were directed toward the
On March 15 at 5:45 a face-to-face meeting occurred among Waco Sheriff Jack Harwell,
negotiator Byron Sage, Steve Schneider and Wayne Martin. The negotiators believed that
the meeting had been productive and another face-to-face meeting was scheduled for March
17. On March 16 Schneider demanded a copy of the ATF search warrant, which was ultimately
sent in on the 19th. Five audio tapes from relatives were sent in. Schneider then requested that
Phil Arnold or another religious scholar be allowed to discuss the Book of Revelations with them.
He suggested that if a theologian could convince the people that Koresh was wrong, maybe some
40 to 50 people would come out. The log reflects that Arnold had contacted the FBI early in the
stand-off and offered to assist them. A tape of Arnold was later sent into the compound. On
March 17 tapes of released members with positive comments about their release were played
over the loudspeakers. Busses were brought within view of the compound. The loudspeakers
addressed the Davidians telling them the busses were to transport them after their exit. FBI
negotiator Byron Sage went out for the planned face-to-face meeting but no one came out.
On March 18 the FBI began bulldozing material around the compound, including a wood
pile, a dump truck and some fuel tanks. Koresh came to the phone on March 19, assured the
negotiators that he was not going to kill himself and asked them not to destroy any more of the
Davidians' property. He stated that a "new moon" was coming and that they would be coming
out, but they needed more time. Certain documents requested by the Davidians were sent in
that day, including copies of news articles about the stand-off, the ATF search and arrest
warrants, a copy of the firearms act, letters from their attorneys and an audio tape of theologian
Phil Arnold. At 10:00 that night Brad Branch and Kevin Whitcliffe exited the compound. These
two men had been mentioned as people who were leaving the compound on March 12 before
the power had been turned off.
On March 19, 1993, Koresh again disavowed any intention to commit suicide.
On March 20 the FBI agreed to turn off the loudspeakers in honor of the Davidians'
Sabbath. Schneider told the negotiators the afternoon of the 20th that a lot of people might be
coming out. That night Koresh was allowed to speak with Branch and Whitcliffe who had left
the compound and to give them a Bible study over the phone. Shortly after midnight Victorine
Hollingsworth and Anetta Richard exited the compound.
The next morning, on March 21, Rita Riddle and Gladys Ottman exited the compound.
Schneider requested that a female agent search women who left the compound and that request
was granted. Later that afternoon Sheila Martin (wife of David Martin) and Ofelia Santoyo came
out. Sheila Martin was allowed to call back in and speak with her husband. That night Judy
Schneider told the negotiators to give a message to her family telling them to take care of her
daughter Maynah because she will be "detained," suggesting that she was planning to come out
with her daughter.
That evening the negotiators were informed that the on scene commander had decided to
allow clearing of vehicles around the compound. The negotiators opposed this decision, arguing
that as on March 12, it would harm the negotiations to have negative actions taken when many
people had come out and there was talk of others coming out the next day. The night of March
21 and the early morning hours of March 22 the FBI cleared vehicles around the compound,
played loud Tibetan chants on the loudspeakers and used the external floodlights. Schneider
complained to the negotiators that the last time people came out the power was cut off and this
time they were rewarded with the loud music.
On March 22 a letter from SAC Jamar and Sheriff Harwell was delivered into the com-
pound promising the Davidians access to Koresh's teachings while they were in custody and
promising them access to the media. The offer was conditioned upon the release of all
Davidians by noon of March 23. Koresh reportedly threw the letter away and said he did
not believe any of it. Additionally, a letter from the Christian Broadcast Network promising
to air an interview with Koresh if he came out was sent in. The loudspeakers and lights were
turned on again that night.
On March 22 there was also a meeting between the on scene commander and leaders
of the negotiating, tactical and behavioral science elements to assess whether there was any
possibility of getting a large number of people out in the near future. The negotiating team
submitted a memo which stated that "there is no clear indication that a large number of
individuals will depart shortly from the compound." They did state however, that "the long
term prospect for a peaceful resolution remains good." They recommended escalating the
"stress" within the compound, first by demanding the release of all parties by a certain time,
with all vehicles around the compound being removed if the demand was not met. If that
tactic did not work, then the memo recommended that non-lethal tear gas be introduced.
The morning of March 23 Livingstone Fagan exited the compound. He was the last
Davidian to exit during the standoff. Schneider demanded to speak with Fagan after his
release, but Fagan refused to call back into the compound. Schneider told the negotiators
that if their "bosses" had not done all of the negative things, such as cutting the power, shining
bright lights and playing loud music, twenty people would have been out, but now "you may
have to come in and take his carcass out of here."
Over the night from March 23 to 24 Tibetan chants, Christmas music and recordings of
the negotiations were played and the lights were on. On the morning of March 24 Schneider
informed the negotiators that this day was a Sabbath and they would not negotiate that day.
At the daily press briefing on March 24 Koresh was verbally attacked as a liar and a coward
who hides behind children.
On the evening of March 24 Louis Alaniz penetrated the outer and inner perimeters and
entered the compound. The negotiators asked Schneider to send him out, but Schneider refused.
On March 25 Schneider complained about ATF still being involved and called them a "rene-
gade agency." He also complained about the FBI vehicles running over the children's motorcycles.
He complained that bibles were taken from the released persons and about the "broken promise"
because Livingstone Fagan did not call back in.
The negotiators began a new tactic on March 25. They demanded the release of 20 people
by 4:00. No one was released by the deadline so the FBI cleared motorcycles and go-carts from
the grounds. The negotiators then demanded that 10 people be released. There was a discussion
of exactly who these people would be. The names Julie Martinez, Cliff Sellars, Clive Doyle, Pablo
Cohen, David Thibodeau, Sherry Doyle, David Jones, Scott Sonobe and Livingstone Malcolm
were discussed. The negotiators were allowed to speak directly to several members about coming
On March 26 the negotiator told Schneider that 10 people must come out by noon.
The negotiators' log reflects that Schneider became angry and said that "These people don't
care! You can kill us whatever, these people fear God (not you)." The log reflects on
March 25 an interview with Lisa Gent, mother of Peter and Nicole, in which she reported
that Peter may have known of plans for a mass suicide. On March 26 Dr. Bruce Perry, a
psychiatrist from Baylor University who interviewed the released children, reported that
he suspected the children may have heard talk about suicide from adults.
As the deadline approached, Schneider reported to the negotiator that he had talked to
people but no one wanted to come out. In response the FBI cleared vehicles and trees from
around the compound. The negotiators told Schneider that no one would be allowed to come
outside the compound. Previously the Davidians had been allowed to come out and feed the
chickens. The negotiators were unable to contact the Davidians by telephone from 5:00 the
afternoon of the 26th until the next morning, when the Davidians hung a banner out reading
that the "tanks broke phone line." On March 26 Jesse Amen penetrated the perimeter and
entered the compound, and the negotiators' log reflects an exit interview with a Davidian in
which a plan was reported for a mass suicide by explosives on March 2 when Koresh had
promised to come out.
At noon on March 27 a box was delivered to the compound containing two blank video
tapes,two batteries for the video camera and a letter from Bill Austin, Chaplain at Baylor, stating
that Koresh had a Biblical obligation to come out peacefully. After that day's press briefing,
Schneider expressed hatred of the ATF and displeasure over the ATF's continued involvement in
the daily press conferences. The ATF spokesman had referred to drugs in the compound, which
had outraged Schneider. It was also reported in that day's press conference that Kathy Schroeder
was going to be charged with conspiracy to commit murder. Previously she had been held only as a
On March 27 the negotiators renewed their tactic of demanding the release of 10 people
by a deadline. The deadline was not met and the FBI bulldozed the front fence. Schneider spent
most of that day on the telephone with the negotiators. He told them the property damage did
not matter because he was going "beyond this world." Schneider threatened that if the Davidians
wanted to kill the FBI agents they could do so and said the FBI could burn the compound down
or kill them. He expressed concern that if he came out he would be charged, concern about what
would happen to him in jail and fear of the other inmates. He also stated that he knew Koresh
would be executed if he came out. He said because Kathy Schroeder was charged with murder, he
does not think anyone else will come out. However, Schneider affirmed that he was not going to
commit suicide. Schneider asked if he could speak with an FBI chaplain and suggested a face-to
-face meeting with his attorney, Jack Zimmerman, Sheriff Harwell and the chaplain from Baylor
who had sent in the letter. Schneider told the negotiator that what would work would be to
"throw a match to the building, people will have to come out." Koresh had not come to the
phone for days, despite repeated requests by the negotiators. Schneider said he was sick.
On March 27, 1993 the negotiator asked Schneider if he was going to commit suicide and
he said "Oh, of course not. If I did I'd be lost eternally." On March 28, 1993 Koresh told the
negotiator that "if we was going to commit suicide, we'd have been dead a long time ago."
On March 28 the negotiators demanded that 10 people come out by 12:50. The deadline
was not met. Koresh finally came to the telephone that afternoon and told the negotiators he knew
his life would be over once he went into their hands. He said he knew he would be charged with
murder when he came out. He requested six gallons of milk and they were sent in. On that day
several people tried to enter the compound but were apprehended.
During the clearing operations on March 28 the adults held children up to the windows.
Concern is reflected on the log that they might use the children as shields if fighting broke
out. That night Koresh was allowed a privileged telephone conversation with Dick DeGuerin,
the attorney his mother hired to represent him. The FBI cleared out the ATF trucks and horse
The Davidians sent out another videotape on March 28. Dr. Bruce Perry reviewed the tape and
reported his opinion that the children were frightened of Koresh and that Koresh was following
a deliberate plan of deception and had his own plan for ending the standoff in an apocalyptic way. Dr.
Perry expressed the belief that Koresh was stalling for a final battle and wanted law enforcement
to go into the compound so he could take some of them with him. This opinion is reflected in the
negotiators' log on April 1.
On March 29 attorney DeGuerin was allowed to go to the front door and have a private
conversation with Koresh.
On March 30 and 31 two justice department officials, Mark Richard and Jim Reynolds, traveled
to Waco. They were briefed by the FBI commanders on scene and viewed the compound. They met
with representatives of the U.S. Attorneys' office and the Texas Rangers. On April 1 they returned to
Washington and reported to the Attorney General and Associate Attorney General Webster Hubbell
on their assessment of the situation. As a result of that trip changes were made in the prosecutive
team to improve coordination among the investigative agencies and the prosecutors. on April 2 Ray
Jahn, a senior Assistant U.S. Attorney in San Antonio, was designated to head the prosecutive team.
On March 30 and 31 attorney DeGuerin was allowed to go into the compound. On April 1
DeGuerin was allowed to go in with attorney Jack Zimmerman, who was hired by Schneider's
family. When the attorneys were debriefed on April 1 they reported that Koresh said he would
come out after Passover. They said that they advised the members not to speak with law enforce-
ment. There were few conversations between the negotiators and the Davidians during this period.
The Davidians refused to allow the attorneys to come in on April 3 because of their Sabbath,
but the attorneys went in again on April 4. The attorneys reported after that meeting that they still
had no date for Koresh's Passover, but that a plan had been discussed in which Koresh would
come out first, followed by the women and children and Schneider would come out last. On April
4 Jesse Amen, an individual who had sneaked in during the stand-off, exited the compound.
On April 6 Schneider informed the negotiators that Passover started at sundown that day and
would last 7 days. He later complained of the loudspeakers being on during Passover. Several
individuals came out of the compound and into the courtyard several times over the next few days
and were "flash-banged" by the FBI. 7
On April 7 Mark Richard and Jim Reynolds from the Justice Department returned to Waco
and held a meeting of the leadership of all of the agencies involved in the Branch Davidian matter,
including the FBI, the ATF, the Texas Rangers, the U.S. Attorney's office and the Texas Department
of Public Safety. They returned from their trip on April 9 and reported to the Attorney General that
the FBI had raised the possibility of utilizing tear gas to resolve the standoff at the compound.
On April 9 Schneider was allowed to go out of the compound to light 7 canisters of incense
for religious reasons. When he came out he dropped off a letter from Koresh. There was little
phone contact over these days, but Schneider did complain that the Bradleys were running over
Peter Gent's grave, that the agents were "flipping the finger" at them and that people were being
On April 10 concertina wire was installed around the compound. Schneider informed the
negotiators that they never gave the attorneys a specific time when they would come out. He
brought a second letter from Koresh out of the compound. On April 12 Schneider requested a
copy of a book about the "Koreshians" that he heard about from the negotiators.
On April 12 Department attorneys Jack Keeney, Mark Richard and Jim Reynolds, all
managing attorneys in the Criminal Division, received a general briefing from FBI officials of the
proposed plan to introduce CS gas into the compound if the Davidians did not come out by
the end of Passover. Later that same day a briefing was held at the FBI Command Center for
the Attorney General and the Associate Attorney General on the proposed plan. The plan was
presented not as an all out assault, but as a tactic whereby gas would be inserted in stages,
initially into only one small area of the compound. The goal was to allow exit through uncontam-
inated portions of the compound. The Attorney General requested that she be provided with
more information on the effects of CS gas on pregnant women and children, a military second
opinion on the plan and information on whether it would be possible to cut off the water supply
to the compound.
On April 13 Koresh refused to speak with attorney DeGuerin, but Schneider spoke with
him for a while. Schneider advised that this was the last day of Passover. Koresh agreed to speak
with the attorneys on the phone on April 14 and at that time advised them that he only intended to
leave the compound when he finished a manuscript on the Seven Seals referred to in the Book of
Revelations. Koresh estimated it would take him 14 days. Koresh came on the phone unexpectedly
at midday and preached to the negotiators for five hours nonstop. Several banners were displayed
that day reading "Read Proverbs 1,2,3,4. We Come to Love, Not War", "Let's Have A Beer When
This Is Over", "My Name Is Vega I'm From Hawaii", "Media and FBI Don't Know the Truth. You
You Can't Accept the Truth. We Can Still Have a Few Beers Together", "I'm an American, I Love
America, But BATF Killed My Family and Friends."
On April 14 another meeting was held in the FBI Director's office in which the Attorney
General and Associate Attorney General were briefed on military and medical aspects of
the proposed plan. United States military commanders were present and evaluated the plan
from a military perspective. They reported that rather than a stop and start insertion of the gas,
they would go in full force and gas the whole compound at once. They also reported their
opinion that the HRT had to be pulled out soon because they had been on full alert too long.
A medical doctor reported to the Attorney General on studies of the effects of CS gas
on children, pregnant women and the elderly. The Attorney General directed that a detailed
statement of the plan with supporting documentation be put together. on April 16 Schneider
reported that Koresh was writing the second seal, but that Schneider had not edited the first
seal yet. On April 17 Louis Alaniz, one of the persons who had entered during the stand-off,
exited the compound.
On the afternoon of Saturday, April 17 the Attorney General gave final approval to the plan
to gas the compound on Monday, April 19, 1993. She advised the President of her decision on
Sunday, April 18.
On April 18 the remaining vehicles were cleared from in front of the compound, including
Koresh's prized automobile. Koresh became very upset about his car. Milk was delivered into
the compound on the 18th along with typewriter equipment.
At approximately 6:00 a.m. on April 19 the gassing operation began. Negotiator Byron
Sage telephoned the compound and notified Steve Schneider that the FBI would be inserting tear
gas, but that it was not a lethal assault and they should all come out peacefully. Schneider
responded by ripping out the phone and throwing it out the door. Sage continued to announce
over the loudspeaker that this was not a lethal assault and to instruct the people on how to exit
and receive medical care. The Davidians fired on the vehicles as they approached the compound.
At noon, fire erupted from three separate areas of the compound. The fire spread quickly,
but the openings in the building appeared to provide a means of escape. Only nine Davidians
survived the fire. They were Renos Avraam, Jamie Castillo, Graeme Craddock, Clive Doyle,
Misty Ferguson, Derek Lovelock, Ruth Ottman Riddle, David Thibodeau and Marjorie Thomas.
A total of 35 people left the compound during the stand-off. Twenty-one children were released
from the compound beginning on February 28, 1993, but no children were released after March 5,
1993. Thus, all of the children were released in the first 6 days of the 51-day stand-off. A total of
14 adults exited the compound during the standoff. Two adults entered the compound during the
stand-off. Both exited before April 19. No Davidian members exited the compound after March
23, 1993 until April 19.
After the fire an independent arson investigation determined that the fire had been started
deliberately by persons inside the compound. The medical examiner found the remains of
seventy five individuals in the debris. Thirteen adult bodies had fatal gunshot wounds. Most
of these wounds were gunshot wounds to the head. Several adults died of gunshot wounds
to the chest and face. Two adults were fatally shot in the back. Three young children were
shot to death and one three year old boy was fatally stabbed in the chest. Two other minors
suffered fatal blows to the head. Koresh died of a gunshot to the mid-forehead. Schneider
died of a gunshot wound of the mouth. The bodies of Koresh and Schneider were found in the
communication room of the compound.
An examination of the burned ruins of the compound by independent arson experts concluded
that the fire was deliberately set from within the compound. It is not clear whether the decision to set
the fire was a unanimous decision of the entire group, or whether some people were held hostage or
were shot to prevent their escape from the fire. A number of children were shot to death.
The Arson Report states:
This fire was caused by the intentional act(s) of a person or persons inside the compound.
Fires were set in three separate areas of the structure identified as points of origin 1, 2
and 3. This investigation establishes that these fires occurred in areas significantly distant
from each other and in a time frame that precludes any assumption of a single ignition source
or accidental cause....Investigative findings further confirm that flammable liquids
were used to accelerate the spread and intensity of the fire.
The Arson Report notes that in addition to the multiple origin points and flammable accelerants,
the spread of the fire was enhanced because the compound was constructed with no consideration
for fire safety, the strong wind from the south intensified the spread and the building contained highly
combustible materials, such as baled hay.
There is also evidence from the Davidians who survived the fire suggesting that the fire was
deliberately set. In a statement given to the Texas Rangers on April 20, 1993 a Davidian stated
that the fire was started with Coleman fuel which had been distributed throughout the compound
in specific locations. Another surviving Davidian was interviewed by the Texas Rangers on April
19, 1993 and stated that he was in the chapel with several other people when the armored
vehicle drove through the front door and he heard the word passed to "start the fires" or
"light the fire," and heard someone else say "make sure." Agent Lloyd Sigler, who spoke with
him immediately upon his exit from the compound, reported him saying that Koresh had
previously spoken of burning the compound if confronted by police. In a May 7 interview that
same Davidian confirmed hearing a conversation about lighting a fire and stated that he thought
there was some plan to burn the building and that he recalled seeing someone deliberately
splashing, pouring or dousing the Chapel area with lantern fuel.8
REDACTED FROM PUBLIC REPORT PENDING RELEASE
OF IMPOUNDED MATERIAL.
REDACTED FROM PUBLIC REPORT PENDING RELEASE
OF IMPOUNDED MATERIAL.
The infra red film taken from an airplane at the time the fire started shows intense spots
of heat erupting in different spots in the compound at almost the same time. These locations
were too far removed from each other to have been ignited by the same source. In addition,
many of the HRT personnel who were within sight of the compound when the fire started report
that they saw flames erupt almost simultaneously in different locations in the compound.
The Arson Report concludes that the fire was started by persons inside the compound
and not by the activities of the FBI vehicles. "We are of the opinion that these [tear gassing]
operations did not contribute to the ignition or spread of the fire." The report does not
rule out the possibility that the spread of the fire could have been enhanced by spillage of
flammables caused by the FBI breaching activities. However, given the significant evidence
that the Davidians were deliberately spreading fuel around the compound, there is no reason
to believe that any such spillage would have been a primary factor in the spread of the fire.
The Arson Report also states that the law enforcement breaching operation opened holes in
the compound that allowed the wind into the compound, possibly enhancing spreading, but it
recognizes that at the same time the fresh air may have also given people more time to escape
before they were overcome with fumes from the burning compound.
The medical examiner has determined that Koresh, Schneider and a number of other individuals
who died in the compound on April 19, did not die from the fire, but died from gunshot wounds. It is
not known whether these individuals committed suicide or were shot by others.
Former Davidian Dana Okimoto reported to authorities in an interview on May 27, 1993,
after the fire, that Koresh's biggest fear was that someone would take his wives away and that he
felt that rather than letting someone take his wife, the wife should kill herself and if she could not
do so one of the "mighty men"10 should do it, since this was one of their duties. Therefore, if people
were shot within the compound it may have been in accordance with the above plan. It is also
possible that some people were shot to prevent their escape from the compound. We may never
know what really happened.11
The stand-off with the Davidians presented a significant danger to the FBI personnel who
were stationed within range of the compound's weaponry. Investigation by the ATF revealed
that by February 28, 1993 Koresh and his associates had at least 243 total firearms, including
two 50 caliber semi-automatic rifles, numerous assault rifles, shotguns, revolvers and pistols.
The Davidians also purchased hundreds of grenades and 39 "full auto sears" devices used to
convert semi-automatic weapons into automatic weapons. On February 28 shots were fired
from over forty different positions within the compound. The Davidians were trained in the use
of these weapons. Moreover, there was concern that the Davidians had dug tunnels fanning
out from the compound and planned to place explosives in the tunnels under FBI positions.
There is no evidence of any shots being fired at the compound by law enforcement officers
after the cease fire on February 28, 1993.12 We have reviewed the statements of the agents who
participated in the tear gas assault on April 19, 1993 and none of them claim to have fired their
weapons on April 19. SAC Jamar and ASAC Rogers both state that the FBI did not fire on
the compound that day. However, rounds were being fired from the compound at the FBI on
April 19th. Also, agents reported hearing gunfire within the compound.
The FBI demonstrated admirable restraint in not firing back on April 19 and thereby avoided
being provoked into a gun battle with the Davidians. Outside agencies present on April 19 praised
the FBI's professionalism in their execution of the gas assault.
The risk of a mass suicide was considered as a possibility during the planning and approval
of the final assault. For example, cyanide poisoning was thought to be a major risk and there-
fore cyanide antidote kits were available on the scene along with an emergency medical facility.
The Attorney General asked about the possibility of a mass suicide.
The evidence of a possible intention to commit mass suicide was contradictory. In a memo
dated March 8 FBI behavioral scientists reported:
KORESH always talks about the "end", suggesting to his followers that "it is closer than
you think". If KORESH dies before his followers, the women are to kill themselves and
the children. If the women are unable, the men are to help them. KORESH teaches his
followers that they must follow him to the "end", even if that means killing themselves....
KORESH realizes that in an environment outside of the compound, without his control
over the followers, he would lose his status as the Messiah, thus a mass suicide ordered
by KORESH cannot be discounted. His order for a mass suicide would be his effort to
maintain the ultimate control over his group, in the event of his death.
(emphasis added). Expert Park Dietz reported that he informed SAC Ricks that Koresh was
suicidal and may have made a suicide pact with other members.
Former members and released members also warned of the possibility of suicide. On March 3,
1993 the FBI interviewed Kiri Jewell, a young teenager who lived in the compound with her mother
until shortly before the stand-off. Kiri reported that the Davidians had discussed mass suicide by
cyanide and shooting themselves. She reported that she believed the mass suicide would occur on a
Friday at 1:00 because that is when Koresh believes Jesus died.
A Davidian who left the compound in mid-March was interviewed in the hospital by Texas
Rangers four times from March 24 to March 27 and reported that the Davidians had planned
mass suicide on March 2, 1993, when Koresh had promised to come out of the compound with all
his followers. Koresh planned to exit the compound with Greg Summers, who would have an
explosive device strapped around his waist so that they would blow themselves up in front of the
FBI. In addition, the people, inside the compound planned to blow themselves up so that "We
would all go to heaven that day".
The Davidian also reported telling Margarida Vaega that he preferred to go to sleep and Vaega
responding that she had an injection that would put him to sleep before the explosion. The Davidian
reported that the plan was not implemented because God, told Koresh to wait since God had more
work for Koresh to do. Vaega pinned a note to her daughter's coat in which she said that the adults
would die after the children were released. The note was intended for Vaega's sister.
The psychiatrists who interviewed the released children reported that the children may have
heard discussions of suicide and that some children believed they would never see their parents
again in this life.
However, in interviews with the ATF before March 15, 1993 former Davidians Mark Breault,
Dana Okimoto, Jeanine Bunds and Robyn Bunds, reported that Koresh's teaching was that law
enforcement officers have to be the vehicle for his death in order for his prophesy to come true
and that he cannot kill himself to fulfill his prophesy. Mark Breault, a former Davidian, told that
Koresh taught that the United States government is out to crucify him and that his group would
be killed but they would rise again. Karen Doyle, a follower of Koresh who lived outside the
compound, reported in an interview during the stand-off that Koresh prophesied his own martyr-
dom and that of the group. She stated that to be "exalted" one had to die with Koresh and stated
that she wished she were there at the compound.
Because suicide was seen as a possibility all along, the negotiators frequently asked Koresh
and his followers whether they were going to commit suicide and they were always reassured
that this was against Koresh's teachings.13 An agent who interviewed some of the individuals who
left the compound reported that none of them indicated that suicide was a potential possibility
and in fact indicated that such an act would be against their religion.
The first briefing book presented to the Attorney General states that the strategy was to
"secure the surrender and arrest of all adult occupants of the compound while providing the
maximum possible security for the children within the compound." (Tab B, p. 4). The
negotiators knew they were faced with religious group fanatically devoted to Koresh and his
teachings. It was not certain, however, whether Koresh truly believed his own religious message
or whether he was exploiting his control over his followers for personal gain.
Initially the FBI tried to work within the framework of the Davidians' beliefs to convince
Koresh the standoff was not the apocalyptic event he had prophesied. Evidently Koresh was the
only "expert" in his branch of Branch Davidianism, and so even with advice from religious
scholars, the FBI was unable to influence Koresh's unique interpretation of scripture. The
frustration of working within Koresh's religious framework became apparent when on March 2,
after promising to leave the compound, Koresh said that God had told him to wait. Koresh was
improvising his own theology and was completely beyond the influence of religious arguments
or religious scholars.
Koresh knew that he and other Davidians would be arrested and charged with murder of the
ATF agents. Koresh and others in the compound were acutely aware of the secular consequences
of their acts. Texas has the death penalty by lethal injection. At one point in the negotiations
Koresh joked, "When they give me the lethal injection, give me the cheap stuff, huh?". Efforts were
aimed at convincing Koresh that if he and the others exited the compound they would be treated
well and that they might "beat the rap." Needless to say this tactic was not popular since
it implicitly criticized ATF and could be viewed as disparaging of the four dead ATF agents.
However, the tactic was completely proper in the context of negotiating a nonviolent end to
In the face of Koresh's intransigence the final negotiating strategy was developed called
the "trickle, flow, gush" strategy. The objective was to undermine the devotion of individual
members to Koresh. The FBI began speaking to the other members on the phone, playing tapes
of the negotiations and the statements of released members and family members back into the
compound over loud speakers, sending videotapes and pictures of the released children into the
compound and sending in messages from family members. For example, a taped passage from
the negotiations in which Special Agent Byron Sage outwitted Koresh was played over the
loudspeakers for this purpose. The objective was to move the pace of the exodus from the
compound from a trickle to a flow to a mass desertion of Koresh by his followers.
Although others left the compound, this strategy also failed. The number of people leaving
the compound slowed rather than accelerated and the exit of members from the compound
stopped altogether after March 23rd, nearly a month before the final assault. There is evidence
that Koresh was purging his group and therefore these departures from the compound did not
represent defections from Koresh's ranks. Many of the adults leaving the compound appeared
to remain loyal to Koresh.
Koresh broke his promises to leave the compound, and the pace of the releases did not
significantly increase. Koresh had promised to come out on March 2nd if the government
played his tape. The government complied and Koresh reneged. Koresh said he was waiting
for a sign from God. On March 12 he considered the guitar nebula as a possible sign, but
decided it was not the sign he was waiting for. Koresh told his lawyers he would come out
after Passover, but when Passover ended, Koresh said he had not committed to a specific
date to come out.15 Koresh continued to make excuses to stay in the compound thus reinforcing
the view that he was not devout, only manipulative.16
Dr. Park Dietz, a Clinical Professor of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences at the University
of California, was consulted by the FBI. Dr. Dietz is under contract with the FBI as a forensic
psychiatrist. The FBI flew Dr. Dietz to Mt. Carmel to give his assessment of Koresh. March
2nd Dr. Dietz expressed the opinion that Koresh would not voluntarily leave the compound. He
considered Koresh to be suicidal and stated that Koresh might have made a suicide pact with his
followers. Dr. Dietz described Koresh's personality as manipulative.
Dr. Dietz made a number of recommendations based on his review of documents and the
negotiations up to that point. He recommended that the FBI distance itself from ATF and
express sympathy with Koresh's anti-BATF views. Dr. Dietz expressed the opinion that Koresh
would choose death over losing power, and therefore the negotiation strategy should create the
illusion that Koresh would not go to prison but would emerge with more followers than he had
Conflicts were reported between the negotiators and the tactical elements regarding the
strategy to be used with the Davidians.17 On several occasions tactical pressure was exerted
on the Davidians either without consulting the negotiators or over the negotiators' objections.
The negotiators believed the timing of these tactical activities disrupted the progress of the
negotiations unnecessarily. Additionally, negotiators complained that the HRT engaged in
tactical maneuvers before the negotiators had an opportunity to use the maneuvers to further
the bargaining process.
At the outset of the crisis FBI behavioral scientists recommended against confronting David
Koresh. The negotiators specifically recommended that the Bradley vehicles should not be
brought up to the compound. Despite the negotiators' advice, the Bradleys were run up and
down in front of the compound in what negotiators believed was a show of force.
On March 12 after two Davidians had exited the compound the decision was made to turn off
the electricity in the compound. The negotiators objected to the decision arguing that the Davidians
should be rewarded for releasing two people. The power was turned off. No one was released
for the next seven days.
On March 21 after seven Davidians had exited the compound the negotiators were advised
that the Davidian vehicles would be cleared from the left side of the compound. The negotiators
opposed this action, pointing out that once again the FBI would be answering a positive move on
the part of the Branch Davidians by a negative action. Nonetheless, the bulldozing was implemented.
The negotiators received conflicting justifications for the action being told both that the items
were being moved as a safety measure and to harass the Davidians.
Loudspeakers were initially used to provide information to Koresh's followers still inside
the compound, but contrary to the negotiators' advice the loudspeakers were used to broadcast
Tibetan chants, other annoying music and the sounds of dying rabbits. The negotiators objected
to playing music as a harassment tactic, advising that such "psychological warfare" would only
make the FBI look bad.
Some negotiators believe that as a result of these actions the Davidians concluded that the
negotiators had no influence over the decision makers and that the FBI was not trustworthy.
Several negotiators and behavioral scientists expressed the opinion that although David Koresh
and his core followers may never have come out through negotiation, more people might have
exited the compound voluntarily during the stand-off if the negotiation strategy had been
followed more rigorously.
The negotiators recognized that a traditional negotiation tactic is to put pressure on the
subject at times through tactical activities choreographed with a more gentle negotiating approach.
However, a memorandum dated March 5, 1993 from FBI behavioral scientists stated that "[i]n
traditional hostage situations, a strategy which has been successful has been negotiations
coupled with ever increasing tactical presence. In this situation however, it is believed this strategy,
if carried to excess, could eventually be counter productive and could result in loss of life."
Despite these conflicts, I am not confident that more members would have left the compound if
the negotiating strategy had been followed more rigorously. Even though in hindsight the behavioral
assessment of Koresh proved extremely accurate, the most compelling evidence of the resolve
of the Davidians to follow Koresh was their willingness to take their own lives and the lives of their
children in obedience to Koresh. It is this total allegiance to Koresh that was unpredictable. Even
those who left the compound before the fire seemed to remain committed to him. Several expressed
regret that they could not join him in death. Koresh could not be pressured into leaving the compound,
and whatever bound Koresh and his followers was apparently stronger than either force or reason.
The negotiators and tactical team had regular access to the SACs on scene and frequently
spoke to them on a one to one basis. However, some negotiators believe that joint strategy
meetings of tactical, negotiating, and command elements were held too infrequently. According
to negotiators the first joint strategy meeting was held on March 22. The negotiators were
miles away from the forward command post and rarely came into direct contact with the tactical
One of the Technically Trained Agents ("TTA,'s") charged with providing technical support
reported that there were communications problems in the command post and that it seemed
one component did not know what the other was doing. He reported feeling as the service
contingent for the other components the TTA's were often "in the middle," receiving conflicting
instructions or inquiries.
The negotiators reported that they were not satisfied with the quality of the information
flowing from the tactical components to the negotiators. The negotiators complained that the
tactical representative in the command center did not use the RAPID START system, but
generally reported information orally and the negotiators rarely received any written
intelligence information generated by the tactical teams unless they actively sought it out.
Likewise, the tactical units in the forward positions complained about the lack of information
about the negotiations, although they believed that the quality of information they were sending
up from the field was very good. Some of the negotiators realized during the stand-off that
their information was not getting out of the command post and making it to the tactical troops,
even though the negotiators all agreed that the information flow out of the negotiation cell
was excellent. HRT members complained of being "starved for information".
For the stand-off in Waco the FBI called upon the services of the Criminal Investigative