Jury Finds South Carolina Fisherman Guilty of Making False Statements

CHARLESTON, S.C. —A federal jury has convicted Don Michael Rynn, 61, of Augustine, Florida, following a three-day trial. Rynn was found guilty of making false statements on trip reports about the amount and quality of the fish he caught, as well as lying to federal agents.

Evidence obtained in the investigation revealed that Don Michael Rynn managed several commercial fishing vessels in the McClellanville area, which included the Maximum Retriever and Crystal C. The vessels docked at Carolina Seafood, a federally licensed dealer. 

On March 21, 2023, the Maximum Retriever embarked on a commercial fishing trip captained by the defendant’s son, who was told by Rynn to catch as many fish as he could – ignoring federally imposed quotas – which would be taken care of when he got back. The Maximum Retriever returned to McClellanville shortly after midnight on March 27 with almost three times the limit of Snowy Grouper on board, and one and a half times the allowable number of Grey Tilefish. Rynn was waiting for the boat to arrive. Once the Maximum Retriever was in place, the Crystal C was maneuvered so that the two boats were side by side.

Shortly afterwards, and under the direction of Rynn, the deckhands moved fish from the ice hold of the Maximum Retriever to the Crystal C. Additional fish were carried from the Maximum Retriever to Rynn’s truck and were transported to another seafood dealer in Georgetown.

In a mandatory trip report filed shortly thereafter, Rynn reported his catch only up to the limit, hiding the fact that the Maximum Retriever had vastly overfished, and attributing a substantial number to the Crystal C, which hadn’t caught any.

On March 27, 2023, SCDNR received a tip of a suspected commercial fish overage, which led to the subsequent investigation.

The fish transported by Rynn to Georgetown were disposed of in order to evade law enforcement by disguising their source.

On Oct. 30, 2023, Rynn was interviewed by NOAA agents and lied to them, telling them the Snowy Grouper and Tilefish had been contaminated by a fuel spill while at sea, and that he had disposed of them in a dumpster. Rynn further implied that a U.S. Coast Guard report addressing an unlawful discharge into Jeremy Creek was inaccurate and should have been attributed to the Crystal C, which would have bolstered his fuel spill story.  

In total, the Maximum Retriever caught approximately 560 pounds of Snowy Grouper and 450 pounds of Tilefish.

"Those who attempt to circumvent federal fishing regulations and deceive law enforcement will be held accountable. Our marine resources are vital, and we will not tolerate those who prioritize personal gain over sustainable practices and the rule of law,” said Acting U.S. Attorney Brook B. Andrews for the District of South Carolina. “This conviction underscores the collaborative efforts of NOAA and SCDNR in protecting our fisheries and ensuring fair competition for all."

“The prosecution of this case and the jury’s verdict emphasizes the importance of holding violators accountable for the harm caused by lying to law enforcement officers and undermining federal fishery regulations. We work closely with our state joint enforcement partners and other federal agencies to detect and identify potential illegal activity related to federal fisheries regulations,” NOAA Office of Law Enforcement Southeast Division Acting Assistant Director Paige Casey said in a statement. “Through our partnerships, we are able to successfully prosecute and convict individuals, such as in this case, who lie to law enforcement officers and who illegally harvest marine resources that could disrupt our fair-trade market.”

“On behalf of all involved, we extend our deepest gratitude to NOAA, the U.S. Coast Guard, the U.S. Attorney's Office, and our dedicated officers for their unwavering commitment and collaboration in protecting our fisheries, said Colonel Chisholm Frampton of the SCDNR Law Enforcement Division. “Together, we have taken a stand against a blatant disregard for the law, ensuring our vital marine resources are preserved for future generations.”

Rynn faces a maximum penalty of five years in federal prison. He also faces a fine of up to $250,000, restitution, and three years of supervision to follow the term of imprisonment. United States District Judge Richard M. Gergel presided over the trial and will sentence Rynn after receiving and reviewing a sentencing report prepared by the U.S. Probation Office.

This case was investigated by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Association, the United States Coast Guard, the South Carolina Department of Natural Resources and the SCDNR Saltwater Team. Assistant U.S. Attorneys Winston Holliday and Amy Bower are prosecuting the case.

###